Showing posts with label Teodoro Padilla. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teodoro Padilla. Show all posts

Sunday, March 30, 2014

ETHIKOS 1: MeTA-PH, PCPI, PHAP and FDA on launching

(Note: This is an expanded version of the paper that I wrote last Friday.)

Last Thursday night, the ETHIKOS (Ethics in Healthcare) Movement was launched at C3 Events Place in Greenhills, San Juan, Metro Manila. Many participants from different groups and sectors. Some quotes from some speakers that night.


All photos I got from the MeTA Philippines facebook page. Thanks Ian Nuevo.

1. Former Gov. Roberto “Obet” Pagdanganan, MeTA Philippines Chairman

Gov. Obet thanked the participants, particularly the organizations that formed movement – the Medicines Transparency Alliance (MeTA) Philippines, the Coalition for Health Advocacy and Transparency (CHAT), and the British Embassy’s Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO).

Then he introduced the Convenor Group of the ETHIKOS Movement: (1) Princess Nemenzo of WomanHealth, (2) Celia Carlos of the Drugstores Association of the Philippines (DSAP), (3) Girlie Lorenzo of Kythe Foundation, also of the Philippine alliance for Patient Organizations (PAPO); Tony Leachon of the Philippine College of Physicians (PCP), and himself.

He discussed what ETHIKOS is – a movement to encourage ethics in delivering healthcare to the patients, ethics in dealing with healthcare professionals  and other private players in the sector, ethics in government.

2. Atty. Dave Escalona, Philippine Chamber of Pharmaceutical Industry (PCPI) and United Laboratories

Dave said that the local pharma industry is supporting the Mexico City Principles (MCP) for voluntary codes of business ethics in the biopharmaceutical sector. He introduced a similar term, “Manila Principles” where the basis of such code of ethics are the Generics Act of 1998 and the Cheaper Medicines Law of 2008 (RA 9502), and the object of such ethics is the welfare of the patients.

Thus, the Manila Principles should consider TRIPS flexibilities as contained in RA 9502, avoid whenever possible prolonged data exclusivity, disallow frivolous patents, allow early working of soon-expiring patents of innovator drugs. He lamented that many local pharma companies are small and lesser known compared to big multinational pharma.

3. Teodoro “Ted” Padilla, Pharmaceutical and Healthcare Association of the Philippines (PHAP) Executive Director.

Ted narrated that in 1993, the association introduced and adopted a code of ethics called the PHAP Code of Practice. He quoted the late Doc Alberto “Quasi” Romualdez (a former DOH Secretary, founding chairman of MeTA PH) who said that “The most important achievement of PHAP now is that they have made ethical behaviour an import part of their commitment…”

He emphasized that no amount of health reform will be truly universal if people and players ignore the consequences of unethical behaviour. He also expressed support for the FDA to implement the MCP. Then he mentioned the important role of the innovator companies for endlessly producing new medicines which help save lives and improve the quality of life of Filipinos.

4. Kenneth “Ken” Hartigan Go, Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Director-General.

Doc Ken discussed certain FDA guidelines regarding senior government officials (SGOs) who make follow up calls at FDA. There are four possibilities where SGOs:

(a)     to inquire on behalf of his/her private sector associates, or determine the status of a rival company
(b)     to request earlier facilitationof application (expediting or jumping the queue
(c)     to demand aprovals even if the license or product registration is to be denied, or to demand a denial against a rival company, and
(d)     to reverse a regulatory decision.

My comments to some of these points in my next article about ETHIKOS..

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

MeTA 16: Day 1 of Conference 2014

The 2014 Medicines Transparency Alliance (MeTA) Philippines forum 2014 started today, here at the Bayanihan Center of Unilab Complex, Pasig City, Metro Manila. Attendance is big, 100+ people attending. I see many new faces here compared to past MeTA PH fora.

Below, they key speakers, from left: Former Bulacan Gov. Roberto "Obet" Pagdanganan, MeTA Philippines Chairman, gave the Opening Remarks. Dr. Tim Reed, Health Action International (HAI, Amsterdam, the International MeTA Secretariat). Dr. Deirdre Dimancesco of WHO in Geneva, and Dr. Francisco Tranquilino of the UP College of Medicine, also Chairman of the Ethics Committee, Philippine College of Physicians (PCP). He gave the Keynote Speech. 

In his brief speech, Dr. Tim Reed noted that "Multistakeholder engagement is clearly achieved in this forum" as the participants come from different sectors and agencies -- government, corporate and industry players, and civil society organization. 


Dr. Art Catli of the Pharmaceutical and Healthcare Association of the Philippines (PHAP) introduced Dr. Tranquilino. Said that the latter is a very popular, well-sought speaker, giving countless speeches here and abroad; that he is a "terror" teacher at UP; a workshorse, a researcher who has published dozens of academic articles, an ambassador of good will. 

Dr. Tranquilino disclosed his past and present engagement in the pharma industry, most of which were with the innovator companies. He started discussing "striking a balance" between innovation and government regulations. 

Medicines save lives, but developing new medicines now take 11-15 years out of 20 years total patent period. Many compounds that were originally discovered and were patented do NOT become medicines, if they do not pass the various clinical trials for safety, efficacy and other criteria. In the last decade, there was dying of pipelines of new revolutionary drugs, resulting in more mergers and consolidation of big pharma companies.  

The Mexico City Principles (MCP) for voluntary codes of ethics of businesses especially in biopharmaceutical sector was adopted by APEC member countries to help reduce corruption, bribery, and at the same time protect public health. 



The next session was on “Multistakeholder advocacy for adherence to the MCP”. The speakers were, from left: Tomas Marcelo "Beau" Agana, Past President of the Philippine Chamber of Pharmaceutical Industry (PCPI), the federation of domestic or national pharma manufacturers and drugstores; Teodoro "Ted" Padilla, Executive Director of PHAP; Atty. Florina Agtarap of the Department of Justice (DOJ) Office of Competition; Dr. C. Diza of the Food and Drugs Administration (FDA); and Dr. Melissa Guerrero of DOH National Center for Pharmaceutical Access and Management (NCPAM). Moderator was Yolanda Ibarle, MeTA Project Director.

Dr. Guerrero said that there are ethical issues in government processes, they have to address those upfront. She hopes that MeTA Philippines and its multi-stakeholder partners can help the DOH urge the local government units (LGUs) abide by DOH rules on the selection of suppliers, truthful procurement of medicines.


Dr. Diza said that FDA will hopefully develop guidelines or an Administrative Order (AO) specifying what needs to be followed from the MCP.

Beau Agana of PCPI talked about their draft Code of Ethics, an APEC workshop for voluntary code of ethics in 2012. Relationship building becomes problematic in pharmaceutical marketing under information asymmetry condition, he said. Code of Ethics will temper maximizing personal interest of doctors and other 3rd party decision makers, and prioritize patients' interests. He added that  patients have started to turn to pharmacists, not their doctors, in their medicines purchase. 


Ted Padilla of PHAP said that they have their Code of Ethics early, that penalties are imposed on  violating member firms and personel. Monetary sanction, a fine, is more effective in tightening behavior. Transparency is essential, there is no substitute to being transparent and honest, and medical decisions must always be made with the best interest of the patients, he added.

During the open forum, some concerns were raised regarding the procurement process and practices of LGUs, not only of medicines but also medical supplies, equipment and facilities.

My main concern in being involved in topics like this is how civil society and voluntary organizations will have greater role in promoting transparency and competition in the economy. Very often, self-regulation by industry players themselves are better than government regulations, restrictions and politics. Manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers who sell only good quality products because they have concern for their customers, or because they are scared that they will be scandalized if their products are discovered to be unsafe and/or ineffective. 
-----------

See also:
Health Transparency 12: MeTA Philippines Dynamism, October 02, 2012 
Health Transparency 13: MeTA International Visit to Manila, April 16, 2013 

Health Transparency 14: IMS-CHAT Meeting, April 18, 2013, Friday, July 12, 2013 

MeTA 15: Forum 2014 on Healthcare Ethics and Transparency, January 30, 2014