Guys who used to prod fiscally-irresponsible governments (FIGs) to either create new taxes, or hike existing ones, were used to be IMF bureaucrats and consultants, aka “IMF review team”. By the way, is this term “FIGs” been used elsewhere in the past? I don’t know. In case not yet, then I can console myself of being among the first to define that term J. And for that, I call FIGs to refer to those governments, especially of poorer countries, whose concept of “public service” is “tax and tax, spend and spend; those they can’t finance by taxation, borrow and borrow.”
So, during those times, the “IMF review team”, would look and tinker with various fiscal, monetary and macro-economic data, then scare those FIGs whose debts have grown to rather unmanageable levels, that if they want “macro-economic stability”, they should either enact new taxes, or raise existing ones, and at least, never ever entertain proposals for tax cuts. These days, FIGs borrow less from the IMF, WB, and other rich governments institutions. FIGs borrow more from private lenders – bondholders, private commercial and investment banks, and so on.
When FIGs do this, the “review team” that private lenders look up to, are no longer IMF bureaucrats, but private credit ratings companies, also called “global debt watchers”. So, guys from Standard & Poor’s (S&P), Fitch, and there’s a 3rd big company on their league. So when FIGs are in a rut, the ratings technocrats make it big in national and international media by releasing their assessment of the “creditworthiness” of various FIGs. The bigger the fiscal irresponsibility of a government, the lower the creditworthiness and hence, the higher the debt premium (ie, interest rates) that private lenders will charge.
One of those FIGs in this planet is my country, the Philippines. With nearly 1/3 of annual budget of the national government devoted to paying interest payment alone for its domestic and foreign debts, the Philippines is among the “big leagues” in terms of fiscal irresponsibility. There are just too many past debts to pay; too many government personnel and bureaucrats (from national to local governments) to pay salaries; too many pork barrel (from the President to military generals to Senators, Congressmen) to set aside money for, and so on.
Now, the ratings guys are not happy with privatizing government assets, especially shares of stocks or equities, in private firms (see BWorld story for instance, “Deficit cure not in government asset sales”, http://www.bworldonline.com/BW062507/content.php?id=001). I am one of the very few souls in this country who advocate large-scale privatization as the single most important revenue source to drastically retire and reduce those huge public debts, so that some taxes will eventually have to be either slashed, if not abolished. You will note therefore, my dislike for those guys – whether government bureaucrats and politicians, or academics and media people, or technocrats of those international ratings companies – who can utter a deafening silence on FIGs’ tax and tax, spend and borrow attitude, but very vocal in opposing large-scale privatization.
FIGs really distort the incentives system in society. Many of the bright minds in society have been successfully pulled away from entrepreneurship and primary job creators, and diverted to the business of being bureaucrats and politicians, and their international cousins and counterparts – bureaucrats of multilateral institutions and technocrats of ratings agencies.
A discussion venue about the role (and misrule) of big government and high taxes. Also a second website of Minimal Government Thinkers.
Monday, June 25, 2007
Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Tax Cut 5: Tax Imperialism, Privatization (PRPX 2007 Hawaii)
There was a "Pacific Rim Conference" held in Sheraton Waikiki, Honolulu, Hawaii, last May 23-24. The event was jointly sponsored by the State Policy Network (SPN), Americans for Tax Reforms (ATR), International Policy Network (IPN), Asian Forum Japan (AFJ), Lion Rock Institute (LRI), and Grassroot Institute Hawaii. I attended that forum and presented a paper too.
A friend from HK, Andrew Work, Executive Director of Lion RockInstitute, HK (www.lionrockinstitute.org) also presented a paper there on Tax Imperialism. He was attacking the EU, US and Canadian governments who tax, or want to tax, their citizens who are working and living abroad, earn income and have savings there. He says that the "secret" of HK's economic dynamism is its low and simple taxes. Meanwhile, 3 countries in the world are taxing their people abroad -- the US, North Korea and Eritrea!
So, how will the EU, US and Canadian governments tax their citizensabroad? By getting lots of data from them, and those data to be provided by the governments of those countries where their citizens currently live and work. So, imagine the tax spying that will happen around the world!
But the worst part of said Tax Imperialism, is trying to force those countries that have low, simple taxes, to raise those taxes and make the tax compliance more complicated through data mining about theb usinesses and other economic activities of citizens.
Andrew concluded his paper with this call:
People are not static. You cut taxes, you don't expect the volume of economic transactions to remain at the same rate as before. There should be bigger, faster economic activities when people have more money in their pockets or bank accounts due to bigger take-home pay or bigger savings.
-----
Below is a portion of the paper that I presented on the panel on Privatization.
From Privatization to Tax Cut: Some Theoretical Considerations and the Philippine Experience
I. Introduction
II. Theoretical Framework
There are two major schools of thought on the existence of government enterprises. First, that which justifies SOEs’ presence, and second, that suggests no justification for the continued existence of SOEs. The former is the dominant thought advocated not only by politicians, appointed bureaucrats, as well as cronies that benefit from SOEs, but even by many academics and consultants.
A. Theory and rationale why SOEs are created
The main reason given by many governments around the world why they create government corporations and banks or SOEs, is to “further push development”. This position is also supported by many intellectuals, consultants and academics. In a paper, “Raison d’Etre of Public Enterprises, Comparative Review (by ASOSAI, 1985), among the reasons given by the governments of the following countries are:
Bangladesh: Promotion of social policy.
India: Promotion of self-reliance in strategic sectors in the economy.
Indonesia: Participate in business vital and firmly connected with the needs of the people.
Malaysia: Growth and expansion.
Pakistan: Self-reliance, deal with strategic sectors of the national economy.
Sri Lanka: Make investments where there is absence of significant private sector.
Australia: Government control, prestige; specialization for economy and effectiveness.
Japan: Strengthen nation’s power; build-up modern industry.
Korea: Promote public services, generate (additional) state revenues.
In the Philippines, one important framework justifying public enterprises is provided by the Constitution itself. In the 1987 Constitution (Article XII, National Economy and Patrimony), it says:
“Sec. 16… Government-owned or controlled corporations may be created or established by special charters in the interest of the common good and subject to the test of economic viability.”
B. Why creation and maintenance of SOEs is not justified
Not everyone is convinced with the above-stated philosophies, of course. Among those who offered some strict criteria by which government enterprises may be allowed is Friedrich Hayek. In his book “The Constitution of Liberty”, he wrote the following in chapter 15, “Economic Policy and the Rule of Law”:
“But though government may at any moment be best qualified to take the lead in such fields (“public goods, public works”), this provides no justification for assuming that this will always be so and therefore for giving it exclusive responsibility…
“So long as government uses any of its coercive powers, and particularly its power of taxation, in order to assist its enterprises, it can always turn their position into one of actual monopoly. To prevent this, it would be necessary that any special advantages, including subsidies, which government gives to its own enterprises in any field, should also be made available to competing private agencies.”
The second statement implies zero justification for state enterprises., because one important characteristic of public enterprises is their exemption from certain taxes and regulations imposed by the state to private enterprises. This immediately invalidates any claim for “fair play” or “level competition” by government enterprises with private enterprises.
To generalize, when SOEs exist because of any of the following conditions below, the justification for their creation, no matter how noble and developmentalist, evaporates. These conditions are:
(a) SOEs are perennial losers and just live off on annual subsidy and continued cronyism for their existence.
(b) They are “doing well” and churn out positive financial statements (ie, have regular net incomes) because: (i) They have instant big capitalization or equity infusion from taxpayers’ money and hence, need not borrow from anyone. (ii) They enjoy certain privileges like tax-exemptions, hassle-free renewal of business licenses or franchise, or freedom from extortion by national and local politicians. (iii) Their big debts and unpayable liabilities in the past were taken off their backs and passed on to the national government (NG), which the NG passed on to the taxpayers. And lastly, (iv) they are plain monopolies.
Thus, when any or all of these conditions is/are evident, the “promises” depicted in Graph 1 may not materialize at all and SOEs instead could produce opposite results. That is, instead of stabilizing or declining costs while benefits expand, you can have increasing costs while benefits decline.
Aside from the above Hayekian criteria, another theory that can disprove the necessity or justification of SOEs to deliver welfare to society, is the concept of contestable market. A market is “perfectly contestable” if entry and exit of firms is absolutely free (Nicholson, 1995). Governments’ various regulations and business-related taxes and fees already impede entry and exit of players. Introducing state enterprises and their built-in exemption from some of those business regulations, taxation, and even extortion by government bureaucrats and politicians further makes entry and exit of firms costly and risky. And with fewer sellers and producers, a society is courting an oligopolistic, even monopolistic market structure, and people can say “goodbye to choice”.
The free entry and exit of firms produce growth through time. And in the observation of one economist, “Government is the enemy of free entry and exit” (Kling, 2007).
C. Don’t Privatize All, Retain Some
There are some proposals that government corporations should only be created and maintained for (i) large, long-term projects that are beyond the reach of the market, and for (ii) activities with distant payoffs, or with great externalities, either negative or positive, that cannot be brought into the enterprise.
Though such proposal appears “neutral” between the current proliferation of SOEs and zero-SOEs argument, the argument is weak.
On activities with distant pay-offs, the state is "justified" to put up a government enterprise. Suppose there is a project to develop a rice variety that contains anti-malaria, anti-AIDS, anti-polio, anti-hepatitis, anti-tuberculoses resistance to people who eat that rice. That is a very "distant pay-off" project. So governments will put up a super-large rice research corporation, and extract super-large taxes from the citizens, to finance that super-large corporation and bureaucracy? That project is too good to be true, and if ever it will materialize, say 100 years from now, then people will be more than willing to save and buy that rice, and will not wait for any government subsidy to give that rice to them at low or zero cost.
On activities with great externalities, government is "justified" to put up a public enterprise. Farming anywhere around the world (rice farming, wheat farming, livestock farming, chicken farming, vegetable farming, fruits farming, etc.) has great externalities, positive and negative. The negative externality is the large-scale conversion of forest land into agricultural land, hundreds of millions of hectares of them. Another negative externality is regular or frequent plowing of the land, which loosens the soil, which aids soil erosion. But farming productivity for some crops will be very low if you do not plow the land and soften the compacted soil.
With such great externality of farming, will governments all over the world be justified to put up super-large farming corporations, or “nationalize” many private farms, to "internalize" those externalities that private farms cannot take in? And again, extract super-large taxes from the citizens, hire super-large bureaucracies, to supervise that super-large corporation?
The proposal therefore, is faulty, or shaky at least. And yet it can be a clever logic to justify statist thinking and intervention into the economy, into our lives, into our pockets....
Conclusions
Large-scale privatization of SOEs (GOCCs and GFIs in the Philippines), preferably all of them (ie, no SOEs left) is in the best interest of taxpayers. Not only that some taxes can be cut, personal income tax can possibly be abolished. When the endless subsidies to ever-losing government corporations and banks, the endless servicing of big public debt, and expansion of the bureaucracy in general has declined, a room for tax cut should be opened.
Some of those government enterprises may have to be sold at a big bargain to expedite their privatization. Proceeds from privatization of SOEs should be used mainly to retire public debts, both foreign and domestic loans, since a big portion of those accumulated public debts were due to the losses, wastes and underperformance of SOEs, both disposed and still existing.
Few or zero SOEs should also reduce cronyism and corruption in the government. This is because appointment to those government enterprises are often used as “rewards” to many supporters of those in the administration, especially those who cannot be given juicy positions in big departments and other agencies. That is why many retired military and police generals become instant presidents or administrators of government enterprises. Likewise, appointment in SOEs is also used to bribe some critics of the administration, including some media people and academics. At least they become silent, better if they become ardent supporters and apologists of the incumbent political leadership.
Privatization is not the end-goal; it is to have a more competitive economy that can harness the entrepreneurial energy and innovative culture of the people. Thus, liberalization and deregulation, if not de-bureaucratization, of the sectors where GOCCs operate should be done before and after privatization. This way, fears and concerns of some people that privatization will only transfer hands from government monopoly to private monopoly, will not happen.
Government should regulate and run after rapists, hold-uppers, drug pushers, carnappers, kidnappers, murderers, land-grabbers, extortionists, arsonists, other forms or variants of thieves and killers. There are so many criminals to regulate and "control" that the state should be very busy running after them. If the state should also busy itself with putting up so many corporations and bureaucracies, then there is a danger that the state can become a robber itself -- robbing the legitimate incomes and savings of the citizens for endless taxes and fees to finance those endless corporations and bureaucracies.
A friend from HK, Andrew Work, Executive Director of Lion RockInstitute, HK (www.lionrockinstitute.org) also presented a paper there on Tax Imperialism. He was attacking the EU, US and Canadian governments who tax, or want to tax, their citizens who are working and living abroad, earn income and have savings there. He says that the "secret" of HK's economic dynamism is its low and simple taxes. Meanwhile, 3 countries in the world are taxing their people abroad -- the US, North Korea and Eritrea!
So, how will the EU, US and Canadian governments tax their citizensabroad? By getting lots of data from them, and those data to be provided by the governments of those countries where their citizens currently live and work. So, imagine the tax spying that will happen around the world!
But the worst part of said Tax Imperialism, is trying to force those countries that have low, simple taxes, to raise those taxes and make the tax compliance more complicated through data mining about theb usinesses and other economic activities of citizens.
Andrew concluded his paper with this call:
"Continue to encourage your local government to engage in tax competition by simplifying and lowering taxes and resist tax imperialism wherever it rears its ugly head. The global network of business and the great experiment of humanity depend on our success in keeping the world free."I say "Amen" to that. In the Philippines, there is realization even by Department of Finance (DOF) people that the country's taxes are among the highest (not to mention among the plentiest) in Asia. But they are in quandary where to get additional revenues if they cut down existing tax rates since there are lots of public debts to pay, millions of government employees to pay, and so on.
People are not static. You cut taxes, you don't expect the volume of economic transactions to remain at the same rate as before. There should be bigger, faster economic activities when people have more money in their pockets or bank accounts due to bigger take-home pay or bigger savings.
-----
Below is a portion of the paper that I presented on the panel on Privatization.
From Privatization to Tax Cut: Some Theoretical Considerations and the Philippine Experience
I. Introduction
II. Theoretical Framework
There are two major schools of thought on the existence of government enterprises. First, that which justifies SOEs’ presence, and second, that suggests no justification for the continued existence of SOEs. The former is the dominant thought advocated not only by politicians, appointed bureaucrats, as well as cronies that benefit from SOEs, but even by many academics and consultants.
A. Theory and rationale why SOEs are created
The main reason given by many governments around the world why they create government corporations and banks or SOEs, is to “further push development”. This position is also supported by many intellectuals, consultants and academics. In a paper, “Raison d’Etre of Public Enterprises, Comparative Review (by ASOSAI, 1985), among the reasons given by the governments of the following countries are:
Bangladesh: Promotion of social policy.
India: Promotion of self-reliance in strategic sectors in the economy.
Indonesia: Participate in business vital and firmly connected with the needs of the people.
Malaysia: Growth and expansion.
Pakistan: Self-reliance, deal with strategic sectors of the national economy.
Sri Lanka: Make investments where there is absence of significant private sector.
Australia: Government control, prestige; specialization for economy and effectiveness.
Japan: Strengthen nation’s power; build-up modern industry.
Korea: Promote public services, generate (additional) state revenues.
In the Philippines, one important framework justifying public enterprises is provided by the Constitution itself. In the 1987 Constitution (Article XII, National Economy and Patrimony), it says:
“Sec. 16… Government-owned or controlled corporations may be created or established by special charters in the interest of the common good and subject to the test of economic viability.”
B. Why creation and maintenance of SOEs is not justified
Not everyone is convinced with the above-stated philosophies, of course. Among those who offered some strict criteria by which government enterprises may be allowed is Friedrich Hayek. In his book “The Constitution of Liberty”, he wrote the following in chapter 15, “Economic Policy and the Rule of Law”:
“But though government may at any moment be best qualified to take the lead in such fields (“public goods, public works”), this provides no justification for assuming that this will always be so and therefore for giving it exclusive responsibility…
“So long as government uses any of its coercive powers, and particularly its power of taxation, in order to assist its enterprises, it can always turn their position into one of actual monopoly. To prevent this, it would be necessary that any special advantages, including subsidies, which government gives to its own enterprises in any field, should also be made available to competing private agencies.”
The second statement implies zero justification for state enterprises., because one important characteristic of public enterprises is their exemption from certain taxes and regulations imposed by the state to private enterprises. This immediately invalidates any claim for “fair play” or “level competition” by government enterprises with private enterprises.
To generalize, when SOEs exist because of any of the following conditions below, the justification for their creation, no matter how noble and developmentalist, evaporates. These conditions are:
(a) SOEs are perennial losers and just live off on annual subsidy and continued cronyism for their existence.
(b) They are “doing well” and churn out positive financial statements (ie, have regular net incomes) because: (i) They have instant big capitalization or equity infusion from taxpayers’ money and hence, need not borrow from anyone. (ii) They enjoy certain privileges like tax-exemptions, hassle-free renewal of business licenses or franchise, or freedom from extortion by national and local politicians. (iii) Their big debts and unpayable liabilities in the past were taken off their backs and passed on to the national government (NG), which the NG passed on to the taxpayers. And lastly, (iv) they are plain monopolies.
Thus, when any or all of these conditions is/are evident, the “promises” depicted in Graph 1 may not materialize at all and SOEs instead could produce opposite results. That is, instead of stabilizing or declining costs while benefits expand, you can have increasing costs while benefits decline.
Aside from the above Hayekian criteria, another theory that can disprove the necessity or justification of SOEs to deliver welfare to society, is the concept of contestable market. A market is “perfectly contestable” if entry and exit of firms is absolutely free (Nicholson, 1995). Governments’ various regulations and business-related taxes and fees already impede entry and exit of players. Introducing state enterprises and their built-in exemption from some of those business regulations, taxation, and even extortion by government bureaucrats and politicians further makes entry and exit of firms costly and risky. And with fewer sellers and producers, a society is courting an oligopolistic, even monopolistic market structure, and people can say “goodbye to choice”.
The free entry and exit of firms produce growth through time. And in the observation of one economist, “Government is the enemy of free entry and exit” (Kling, 2007).
C. Don’t Privatize All, Retain Some
There are some proposals that government corporations should only be created and maintained for (i) large, long-term projects that are beyond the reach of the market, and for (ii) activities with distant payoffs, or with great externalities, either negative or positive, that cannot be brought into the enterprise.
Though such proposal appears “neutral” between the current proliferation of SOEs and zero-SOEs argument, the argument is weak.
On activities with distant pay-offs, the state is "justified" to put up a government enterprise. Suppose there is a project to develop a rice variety that contains anti-malaria, anti-AIDS, anti-polio, anti-hepatitis, anti-tuberculoses resistance to people who eat that rice. That is a very "distant pay-off" project. So governments will put up a super-large rice research corporation, and extract super-large taxes from the citizens, to finance that super-large corporation and bureaucracy? That project is too good to be true, and if ever it will materialize, say 100 years from now, then people will be more than willing to save and buy that rice, and will not wait for any government subsidy to give that rice to them at low or zero cost.
On activities with great externalities, government is "justified" to put up a public enterprise. Farming anywhere around the world (rice farming, wheat farming, livestock farming, chicken farming, vegetable farming, fruits farming, etc.) has great externalities, positive and negative. The negative externality is the large-scale conversion of forest land into agricultural land, hundreds of millions of hectares of them. Another negative externality is regular or frequent plowing of the land, which loosens the soil, which aids soil erosion. But farming productivity for some crops will be very low if you do not plow the land and soften the compacted soil.
With such great externality of farming, will governments all over the world be justified to put up super-large farming corporations, or “nationalize” many private farms, to "internalize" those externalities that private farms cannot take in? And again, extract super-large taxes from the citizens, hire super-large bureaucracies, to supervise that super-large corporation?
The proposal therefore, is faulty, or shaky at least. And yet it can be a clever logic to justify statist thinking and intervention into the economy, into our lives, into our pockets....
Conclusions
Large-scale privatization of SOEs (GOCCs and GFIs in the Philippines), preferably all of them (ie, no SOEs left) is in the best interest of taxpayers. Not only that some taxes can be cut, personal income tax can possibly be abolished. When the endless subsidies to ever-losing government corporations and banks, the endless servicing of big public debt, and expansion of the bureaucracy in general has declined, a room for tax cut should be opened.
Some of those government enterprises may have to be sold at a big bargain to expedite their privatization. Proceeds from privatization of SOEs should be used mainly to retire public debts, both foreign and domestic loans, since a big portion of those accumulated public debts were due to the losses, wastes and underperformance of SOEs, both disposed and still existing.
Few or zero SOEs should also reduce cronyism and corruption in the government. This is because appointment to those government enterprises are often used as “rewards” to many supporters of those in the administration, especially those who cannot be given juicy positions in big departments and other agencies. That is why many retired military and police generals become instant presidents or administrators of government enterprises. Likewise, appointment in SOEs is also used to bribe some critics of the administration, including some media people and academics. At least they become silent, better if they become ardent supporters and apologists of the incumbent political leadership.
Privatization is not the end-goal; it is to have a more competitive economy that can harness the entrepreneurial energy and innovative culture of the people. Thus, liberalization and deregulation, if not de-bureaucratization, of the sectors where GOCCs operate should be done before and after privatization. This way, fears and concerns of some people that privatization will only transfer hands from government monopoly to private monopoly, will not happen.
Government should regulate and run after rapists, hold-uppers, drug pushers, carnappers, kidnappers, murderers, land-grabbers, extortionists, arsonists, other forms or variants of thieves and killers. There are so many criminals to regulate and "control" that the state should be very busy running after them. If the state should also busy itself with putting up so many corporations and bureaucracies, then there is a danger that the state can become a robber itself -- robbing the legitimate incomes and savings of the citizens for endless taxes and fees to finance those endless corporations and bureaucracies.
Labels:
Americans for Tax Reforms,
flat tax,
Grassroot Institute,
International Policy Network,
Lion rock institute,
privatization,
State Policy Network,
tax cut,
tax imperialism
Wednesday, May 30, 2007
Foreign Aid 7: Wolfowitzoellickation of the WB
Out Mr. Paul Wolfowitz, an American, as World Bank (WB) President by June 30 this year. Coming in will be Mr. Robert Zoellick, an American, as another WB President.
Wolfowitz fell from grace after a big scandal where he gave handsome salaries and transfer package to his partner, a former WB official, then transferred to the US state department. Since the scandal broke up about 2 months ago, Wolfowitz has never recovered. What made his stay a bit longer, by about 1 month more, was the hesitation of Mr. Bush to replace him earlier.
Mr. Zoellick is former US Deputy Trade Secretary. If you follow the Iraq war, his name does not appear there. But if you follow WTO news and the Doha round of trade negotiations, Zoellick’s name can appear anytime. Just like most if not all “trade negotiators”, he’s a free trader and protectionist at the same time. That is, they say, “Yes we will liberalize our markets if you liberalize yours too.” Or, “we have to protect our markets because you protect yours too.” At the end of the day, there are always other guys to blame why free trade does not and cannot happen.
Is the WB “owned” by the US government? Not true, because governments of other countries also contribute for the capitalization of that bank. The US government “controls” the WB? Somehow yes, as evidenced by the dictum, “All WB Presidents should be American”, with a sub-title and extension, “And appointed by the US President”. It’s just a matter of finding a “more acceptable” American bureaucrat from America’s deep bench of bureaucracies, to the bureaucrats and politicians of other countries, the big contributors especially, like European and Japan governments. So that when Wolfowitz was cornered in that scandal, he became “unacceptable” not only to many WB staff but also to many representatives of foreign governments who contribute to the WB.
So, the Wolfowitzoellickation of the WB is a continuum of Pres. Bush’s (and all other US Presidents’) international policy to “develop” the world. Part of that policy is hiring tens of thousands of soldiers and gunners to “fight terrorists” in Iraq, Afghanistan, and possibly Iran, elsewhere. Another part is hiring thousands of bureaucrats and economists to “fight poverty” around the world. And a big component of that “fighting poverty” is collecting plenty of taxes from private citizens, and exempting from taxes the bureaucrats who will be the poverty fighters.
But the US government does not own the sole distinction of monopolizing presidency and leadership of a multilateral institution. The Europeans also do it, in its dictum, “All Managing Directors of the IMF should be Europeans”. And the Japs too, with their special banner, “All ADB Presidents should be Japanese”. It’s been the practice in the past, and shall be practiced in more years to come. And so if you work in the WB, IMF, ADB, OECD, other multilateral bodies and institutions, you get the double distinction of being a “poverty fighter” with fat salaries, and at the same time, exempted from income confiscation by any government around the world. Cool deal, right dude?
Meanwhile, I’m curious if Mr. Zoellick will replicate their earlier proposal to governments of poorer countries: “We can’t open up rich countries’ markets that big, but we can increase foreign aid to your governments”. If this happens, then what most of those international trade negotiations will achieve is more to enrich the airlines and hotels flying and housing those trade bureaucrats. After all, those airlines, expensive hotels and restaurants, and their respective owners and personnel pay lots of taxes to pay for the salaries and travels of those trade and foreign aid bureaucrats. Still a cool deal. Yeah man!
-------
The Growing Irrelevance of WB-IMF
For a number of poor and indebted economies like the Philippines, the IMF has become more and more irrelevant. The country remains indebted, yes, but not much to the World Bank and IMF anymore, but to private bondholders. And the bondholders who want to lend to debtor countries don’t look up much to the IMF for “guidance” but to private ratings agencies like S&P, Fitch, Moody’s. So much so that either the IMF should merge with other international bureaucracies to remain relevant, or collapse upon its own weight like a black hole.
The WB, sometimes it competes with the Asian Development Bank and other regional development banks in the world on convincing fiscally-irresponsible governments to borrow more from them. The politicians and bureaucrats, and sometimes the consultants, often have no qualms in wasting those money. If government officials of indebted countries can waste and steal their own people’s money, why not the tax money of the rich Americans, Europeans and Japanese, injected into those foreign aid institutions?
Besides, private financial flows -- like remittances of overseas workers (from rich countries to poor countries) approaching $300 billion a year -- are much bigger than all those foreign aid by rich countries combined. If governance of those poor countries (or better, less governance and less bureaucracies) are improved, then the big amount of such private transfers should translate to more local job creation and more economic growth.
Can a new policy of less aid, less taxes be tried by leaders of rich countries? When their citizens have more money in their pockets through lesser taxes, they’ll use that money to hire workers and nannies from poorer countries. Or buy more mangos, bananas, pineapples, other tropical products from poorer countries. Or visit the tropical white sand beaches, tropical forests and waterfalls, golf courses, of the poorer countries more often. This is a more direct people-to-people transfer of money. Unlike aid which is government-to-government.
---------
See also:
Foreign Aid 1: MDG Goals = More Debt Addiction, October 26, 2005
Foreign Aid 2: Circuitous and Leaky Process, November 03, 2005
Foreign Aid 3: Bob Geldoff and More Aid, November 10, 2005
Foreign Aid 4: Easterly vs. Sachs, May 01, 2006
Foreign Aid 5: Failure in East Timor, May 31, 2006
Foreign Aid 6: IMF is Engineerable and Abolishable, September 05, 2006
Wolfowitz fell from grace after a big scandal where he gave handsome salaries and transfer package to his partner, a former WB official, then transferred to the US state department. Since the scandal broke up about 2 months ago, Wolfowitz has never recovered. What made his stay a bit longer, by about 1 month more, was the hesitation of Mr. Bush to replace him earlier.
Mr. Zoellick is former US Deputy Trade Secretary. If you follow the Iraq war, his name does not appear there. But if you follow WTO news and the Doha round of trade negotiations, Zoellick’s name can appear anytime. Just like most if not all “trade negotiators”, he’s a free trader and protectionist at the same time. That is, they say, “Yes we will liberalize our markets if you liberalize yours too.” Or, “we have to protect our markets because you protect yours too.” At the end of the day, there are always other guys to blame why free trade does not and cannot happen.
Is the WB “owned” by the US government? Not true, because governments of other countries also contribute for the capitalization of that bank. The US government “controls” the WB? Somehow yes, as evidenced by the dictum, “All WB Presidents should be American”, with a sub-title and extension, “And appointed by the US President”. It’s just a matter of finding a “more acceptable” American bureaucrat from America’s deep bench of bureaucracies, to the bureaucrats and politicians of other countries, the big contributors especially, like European and Japan governments. So that when Wolfowitz was cornered in that scandal, he became “unacceptable” not only to many WB staff but also to many representatives of foreign governments who contribute to the WB.
So, the Wolfowitzoellickation of the WB is a continuum of Pres. Bush’s (and all other US Presidents’) international policy to “develop” the world. Part of that policy is hiring tens of thousands of soldiers and gunners to “fight terrorists” in Iraq, Afghanistan, and possibly Iran, elsewhere. Another part is hiring thousands of bureaucrats and economists to “fight poverty” around the world. And a big component of that “fighting poverty” is collecting plenty of taxes from private citizens, and exempting from taxes the bureaucrats who will be the poverty fighters.
But the US government does not own the sole distinction of monopolizing presidency and leadership of a multilateral institution. The Europeans also do it, in its dictum, “All Managing Directors of the IMF should be Europeans”. And the Japs too, with their special banner, “All ADB Presidents should be Japanese”. It’s been the practice in the past, and shall be practiced in more years to come. And so if you work in the WB, IMF, ADB, OECD, other multilateral bodies and institutions, you get the double distinction of being a “poverty fighter” with fat salaries, and at the same time, exempted from income confiscation by any government around the world. Cool deal, right dude?
Meanwhile, I’m curious if Mr. Zoellick will replicate their earlier proposal to governments of poorer countries: “We can’t open up rich countries’ markets that big, but we can increase foreign aid to your governments”. If this happens, then what most of those international trade negotiations will achieve is more to enrich the airlines and hotels flying and housing those trade bureaucrats. After all, those airlines, expensive hotels and restaurants, and their respective owners and personnel pay lots of taxes to pay for the salaries and travels of those trade and foreign aid bureaucrats. Still a cool deal. Yeah man!
-------
The Growing Irrelevance of WB-IMF
For a number of poor and indebted economies like the Philippines, the IMF has become more and more irrelevant. The country remains indebted, yes, but not much to the World Bank and IMF anymore, but to private bondholders. And the bondholders who want to lend to debtor countries don’t look up much to the IMF for “guidance” but to private ratings agencies like S&P, Fitch, Moody’s. So much so that either the IMF should merge with other international bureaucracies to remain relevant, or collapse upon its own weight like a black hole.
The WB, sometimes it competes with the Asian Development Bank and other regional development banks in the world on convincing fiscally-irresponsible governments to borrow more from them. The politicians and bureaucrats, and sometimes the consultants, often have no qualms in wasting those money. If government officials of indebted countries can waste and steal their own people’s money, why not the tax money of the rich Americans, Europeans and Japanese, injected into those foreign aid institutions?
Besides, private financial flows -- like remittances of overseas workers (from rich countries to poor countries) approaching $300 billion a year -- are much bigger than all those foreign aid by rich countries combined. If governance of those poor countries (or better, less governance and less bureaucracies) are improved, then the big amount of such private transfers should translate to more local job creation and more economic growth.
Can a new policy of less aid, less taxes be tried by leaders of rich countries? When their citizens have more money in their pockets through lesser taxes, they’ll use that money to hire workers and nannies from poorer countries. Or buy more mangos, bananas, pineapples, other tropical products from poorer countries. Or visit the tropical white sand beaches, tropical forests and waterfalls, golf courses, of the poorer countries more often. This is a more direct people-to-people transfer of money. Unlike aid which is government-to-government.
---------
See also:
Foreign Aid 1: MDG Goals = More Debt Addiction, October 26, 2005
Foreign Aid 2: Circuitous and Leaky Process, November 03, 2005
Foreign Aid 3: Bob Geldoff and More Aid, November 10, 2005
Foreign Aid 4: Easterly vs. Sachs, May 01, 2006
Foreign Aid 5: Failure in East Timor, May 31, 2006
Foreign Aid 6: IMF is Engineerable and Abolishable, September 05, 2006
Labels:
ADB,
foreign aid,
IMF,
Paul Wolfowitz,
Robert Zoellick,
WB
Monday, April 30, 2007
Pol. Ideology 7: Individualism, Entitlement and Freedom
This is one of the exchanges in MG yahoogroups more than six years ago. From welfare, entitlement and taxes, to individualism, personal responsibility and freedom. This is 9 pages long.
------------
Hello Nonoy
I think the welfare system in NZ is more generous than that of Australia's. Here, for instance, there is "no effective" limit on unemployment benefits. A single mother with 2 or more dependents may actually receive more in benefits (net of taxes) than if the single mother were to work in a minimum wage-paying job. And this is one reason why the marginal income tax rates in NZ are also among the highest in the OECD and the problem too is that the top income tax rate of 39% cuts at a rather low income threshold - NZ$60,000. This is roughly US$39,000 only. So to compare, in New York, the top tax rate (state) is only 7.7% for incomes of US$500,000 (married or single). Am not sure kung how much ang federal income taxes (kung meron man). So, if you're earning an equivalent of US$39,000 in NZ, you're subject to 39% tax, kung nasa New York ka, a little over 4% lang ang tax mo. Also, here in NZ, there are no income tax exemptions. Whether you're single or married, with or without children, you're subject to the same tax rates.
Now, about your comment of 5 workers per person on welfare. This is roughly the same for NZ. Looking at that ratio on its own, it may appear like a high ratio, but if you take into consideration other factors, this ratio isn't high at all. Consider for instance the ageing population in Australia, which is one of their main problems, same with many other European countries and Japan. The ratio of workers to the elderly continues to grow at an alarming rate as the population ages and birth/fertility rates decline. Mawawalan ka ng replacement workers as some of the current workers retire. Ganyan din ang problema dito ... kawawa ang workers aged 30-45, by the time they retire, and if birth rates continue to decline (and immigration policies continue to be quite strict) there won't be enough workers to support their retirement - unfair! Kaya dito, government is trying to promote various retirement schemes to encourage people to save for their own retirement. But how can you sell this idea when people here have always been used to the idea and belief that it is the government's responsibility to take care of them when they retire - kasi they're so used to the welfare system!
This is only one angle, am trying to work on a research paper kasi about the consequences nga of the ageing population of NZ.
- Arlene
------------
Hello Nonoy
I think the welfare system in NZ is more generous than that of Australia's. Here, for instance, there is "no effective" limit on unemployment benefits. A single mother with 2 or more dependents may actually receive more in benefits (net of taxes) than if the single mother were to work in a minimum wage-paying job. And this is one reason why the marginal income tax rates in NZ are also among the highest in the OECD and the problem too is that the top income tax rate of 39% cuts at a rather low income threshold - NZ$60,000. This is roughly US$39,000 only. So to compare, in New York, the top tax rate (state) is only 7.7% for incomes of US$500,000 (married or single). Am not sure kung how much ang federal income taxes (kung meron man). So, if you're earning an equivalent of US$39,000 in NZ, you're subject to 39% tax, kung nasa New York ka, a little over 4% lang ang tax mo. Also, here in NZ, there are no income tax exemptions. Whether you're single or married, with or without children, you're subject to the same tax rates.
Now, about your comment of 5 workers per person on welfare. This is roughly the same for NZ. Looking at that ratio on its own, it may appear like a high ratio, but if you take into consideration other factors, this ratio isn't high at all. Consider for instance the ageing population in Australia, which is one of their main problems, same with many other European countries and Japan. The ratio of workers to the elderly continues to grow at an alarming rate as the population ages and birth/fertility rates decline. Mawawalan ka ng replacement workers as some of the current workers retire. Ganyan din ang problema dito ... kawawa ang workers aged 30-45, by the time they retire, and if birth rates continue to decline (and immigration policies continue to be quite strict) there won't be enough workers to support their retirement - unfair! Kaya dito, government is trying to promote various retirement schemes to encourage people to save for their own retirement. But how can you sell this idea when people here have always been used to the idea and belief that it is the government's responsibility to take care of them when they retire - kasi they're so used to the welfare system!
This is only one angle, am trying to work on a research paper kasi about the consequences nga of the ageing population of NZ.
- Arlene
Wednesday, April 11, 2007
Abolishing income taxes, Retaining consumption taxes
Why income taxes can be abolished,
Consumption taxes as main government
revenue source[1]
Bienvenido “Nonoy” Oplas, Jr.[2]
A. Philosophy/Principle
1. Economic activities by productive individuals and enterprises always (a) create jobs, and (b) expand production of food, housing, clothing, transportation, other human needs. Hence, they already serve welfare functions to society, and they should not be penalized with income taxes and bureaucratic licenses and permits.2. There are plenty of consumption-based taxes already in place. In particular: (a) value added tax or VAT, (b) sales tax, (c) excise tax, (d) import tax, (e) vehicle registration tax, (f) real property tax, (g) percentage tax, (h) amusement tax, (i) travel tax, among others.
3. In addition, various bureaucracy-generated taxes, like (a) documentary stamp tax, (b) franchise tax, (c) bank earnings witholding tax, (d) insurance premium tax, (e) business permit tax, (f) fire code tax, and so on.
4. Very bureaucratic, discretionary, costly and corruption-prone to fully enforce income tax collections since people do not want to divulge their true income; cheaper to hire good accountants and lawyers and bribe revenue collectors than pay the full income tax liability. What the current income tax laws only affect are the fixed-income earners like teachers, office employees, soldiers, and so on.
5. Welfare loss to society = income taxes paid + cost of compliance (hiring accountants, lawyers, other business consultants) + cost of bribery (to avoid paying taxes or bring down their tax liabilities).
6. In addition, many people who live off on taxes, like those working in multilateral institutions (UN, WB, IMF, ADB), in other governments’ foreign aid bodies and embassies, are exempted from mandatory witholding income taxes. The more reason that those working in the private sector, those who derive their income not from taxes of other people but on business sales, should be spared from paying income tax.
B. The Numbers
1. Collections from income tax (P Billion, except %)
(a) From Individuals
2005, 112.68
2006, 132.01
2007, 154.30
(b) From corporations, enterprises, others
2005, 210.75
2006, 263.22
2007, 300.07
Percent of (a) to total tax revenues
2005, 16.0%
2006, 15.0%
2007, 12.8%
Percent of (a+b) to total tax revenues
2005, 45.8%
2006, 44.8%
2007, 37.6%
Total tax revenues *
2005, 705.61
2006, 881.62
2007, 1,208.20
* Not included here are (i) “non-tax revenues” like various fees and charges, Bureau of Treasury (BTr) income, privatization proceeds, and (ii) local government taxes and fees.
(Source: Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing (BESF), 2007)
2. GDP computation
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the sum of household consumptions (C), government consumption (G), private and government investment (I) and net exports (X-M). Alternatively, GDP is also computed as the sum of gross value added (GVA) of agriculture, industry and services sectors. Or:
GDP = C + I + G + (X-M), or
GDP = GVA Agri + GVA Industry + GVA Services.
Nominal GDP figures were:
2003, P4.316 B; 2004, P4.859 B; 2005, P5.419 B; 2006, P6.025.
3. Assumptions when income taxes, at least personal income tax, is zero:
(a) informal or underground economy will fall from 43% ** (WB estimates) to around 20% of GDP (or 80% formal economy); and
(b) GDP growth will be higher as household consumption (C) will increase. And C comprises nearly 75% of GDP; and
(c) VAT to be augmented by a national sales tax, composite consumption tax of 12%; and
(d) all other consumption-based taxes are retained; exemptions to VAT retained.
(** Note: Main culprit for the high incidence of informal sector is the high and multiple taxes and fees, the many permits and licenses to secure with various government agencies, both national and local government units)
4. Projected revenue collections under zero income tax, expanded consumption taxes, on a P8 trillion GDP:
(a) Taxable national income = (nominal GDP) x (formal economy)= (P8 trillion) x (0.80) = P6.4 trillion(b) Projected collections from VAT & sales tax alone
= (taxable income) x (12% VAT & sales tax)= (P6.4 trillion) x (0.12) = P768 billion.
This is equivalent to projected collections of (i) income tax + (ii) general sales & VAT. Projected revenue from (i + ii) in 2007 is P628 billion. As discussed earlier, there are other tax revenues which will not be affected by this initiative, like proceeds from excise tax, franchise tax, property tax.
C. Conclusion
1. One major impact of zero income tax, especially on personal income, is large-scale job creation. A household with combined witholding tax of say, P6,000/month will experience an equivalent “wage increase” of the same amount. That amount will be used to hire a “yaya” (nanny) or housemaid, or increase food consumption if the family size is big, creating new jobs in the food production sectors.
2. In addition, many employees who dream of becoming employers and job creators someday will make it easier to realize their dreams. They do not have to borrow much money as they can save their de facto “pay rise” in the form of zero income tax, for bigger equity in their entrepreneurial project someday.
3. Society’s human resources will be reallocated to more productive use. There will be lesser tax collection bureaucrats, lesser demand for tax consulting services (accounting, legal, PR, etc.) as the taxation system is more simple. If those bureaucrats and income tax consulting guys are into productive enterprises instead, then society’s production of more goods and services will expand, further creating more job opportunities.
4. People often hide their source of income, or how much they’re earning. But they flaunt their consumption – big house, big or fast cars, expensive clothes and cellphones, throwing parties, frequent travels and vacation, and so on. Taxing people on their consumption is much easier to administer because they give clear hints of what are their consumption preferences.
5. Low-income people who paid no or low income tax and low consumption tax before will not be worse off in a new situation where consumption taxes are higher. With plenty of job opportunities around, moving to high-paying jobs should be easier if one has sufficient ambition and industriousness.
6. Ultimately, consumption tax and other taxes must come down; some will have to be abolished too (as income taxes remain zero) – in a regime of small government, and bigger personal responsibilities and bigger role for voluntary organizations and civil society.
D. Timetable
1. The main goal of this taxpayers’ movement is a law that will abolish income tax, and shift revenue collection to consumption-based taxes.
2. To lessen drastic revenue adjustments, that law need not provide outright drop in income tax rate from the current 32% to zero in one year. A phase-in period of gradual reduction from 32% to zero in a period of 5 to 10 years as sales tax increase is being worked out will be instituted.
3. Meanwhile, the immediate task is to expand the number of individuals and organizations who will support this single goal. Existing organizations can affiliate with PTU. Or individuals who do not belong to any organization can form their own local taxpayers association or union (say, Pasig Taxpayers Association) and affiliate with PTU.
4. If we are strong enough, we can push a bill this year, and expect a law within 2 to 3 years (2008 or 2009).
[1] Presented during the forum on “In Search of a National Consensus”, sponsored by the Barangay San Lorenzo Business Association (BSLBA), at My Cinema, Greenbelt 3, Makati City, March 30, 2007.
[2] Secretary-General, Philippine Taxpayers Union (PTU); President, Minimal Government Movement (MGM)
Consumption taxes as main government
revenue source[1]
Bienvenido “Nonoy” Oplas, Jr.[2]
A. Philosophy/Principle
1. Economic activities by productive individuals and enterprises always (a) create jobs, and (b) expand production of food, housing, clothing, transportation, other human needs. Hence, they already serve welfare functions to society, and they should not be penalized with income taxes and bureaucratic licenses and permits.2. There are plenty of consumption-based taxes already in place. In particular: (a) value added tax or VAT, (b) sales tax, (c) excise tax, (d) import tax, (e) vehicle registration tax, (f) real property tax, (g) percentage tax, (h) amusement tax, (i) travel tax, among others.
3. In addition, various bureaucracy-generated taxes, like (a) documentary stamp tax, (b) franchise tax, (c) bank earnings witholding tax, (d) insurance premium tax, (e) business permit tax, (f) fire code tax, and so on.
4. Very bureaucratic, discretionary, costly and corruption-prone to fully enforce income tax collections since people do not want to divulge their true income; cheaper to hire good accountants and lawyers and bribe revenue collectors than pay the full income tax liability. What the current income tax laws only affect are the fixed-income earners like teachers, office employees, soldiers, and so on.
5. Welfare loss to society = income taxes paid + cost of compliance (hiring accountants, lawyers, other business consultants) + cost of bribery (to avoid paying taxes or bring down their tax liabilities).
6. In addition, many people who live off on taxes, like those working in multilateral institutions (UN, WB, IMF, ADB), in other governments’ foreign aid bodies and embassies, are exempted from mandatory witholding income taxes. The more reason that those working in the private sector, those who derive their income not from taxes of other people but on business sales, should be spared from paying income tax.
B. The Numbers
1. Collections from income tax (P Billion, except %)
(a) From Individuals
2005, 112.68
2006, 132.01
2007, 154.30
(b) From corporations, enterprises, others
2005, 210.75
2006, 263.22
2007, 300.07
Percent of (a) to total tax revenues
2005, 16.0%
2006, 15.0%
2007, 12.8%
Percent of (a+b) to total tax revenues
2005, 45.8%
2006, 44.8%
2007, 37.6%
Total tax revenues *
2005, 705.61
2006, 881.62
2007, 1,208.20
* Not included here are (i) “non-tax revenues” like various fees and charges, Bureau of Treasury (BTr) income, privatization proceeds, and (ii) local government taxes and fees.
(Source: Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing (BESF), 2007)
2. GDP computation
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is the sum of household consumptions (C), government consumption (G), private and government investment (I) and net exports (X-M). Alternatively, GDP is also computed as the sum of gross value added (GVA) of agriculture, industry and services sectors. Or:
GDP = C + I + G + (X-M), or
GDP = GVA Agri + GVA Industry + GVA Services.
Nominal GDP figures were:
2003, P4.316 B; 2004, P4.859 B; 2005, P5.419 B; 2006, P6.025.
3. Assumptions when income taxes, at least personal income tax, is zero:
(a) informal or underground economy will fall from 43% ** (WB estimates) to around 20% of GDP (or 80% formal economy); and
(b) GDP growth will be higher as household consumption (C) will increase. And C comprises nearly 75% of GDP; and
(c) VAT to be augmented by a national sales tax, composite consumption tax of 12%; and
(d) all other consumption-based taxes are retained; exemptions to VAT retained.
(** Note: Main culprit for the high incidence of informal sector is the high and multiple taxes and fees, the many permits and licenses to secure with various government agencies, both national and local government units)
4. Projected revenue collections under zero income tax, expanded consumption taxes, on a P8 trillion GDP:
(a) Taxable national income = (nominal GDP) x (formal economy)= (P8 trillion) x (0.80) = P6.4 trillion(b) Projected collections from VAT & sales tax alone
= (taxable income) x (12% VAT & sales tax)= (P6.4 trillion) x (0.12) = P768 billion.
This is equivalent to projected collections of (i) income tax + (ii) general sales & VAT. Projected revenue from (i + ii) in 2007 is P628 billion. As discussed earlier, there are other tax revenues which will not be affected by this initiative, like proceeds from excise tax, franchise tax, property tax.
C. Conclusion
1. One major impact of zero income tax, especially on personal income, is large-scale job creation. A household with combined witholding tax of say, P6,000/month will experience an equivalent “wage increase” of the same amount. That amount will be used to hire a “yaya” (nanny) or housemaid, or increase food consumption if the family size is big, creating new jobs in the food production sectors.
2. In addition, many employees who dream of becoming employers and job creators someday will make it easier to realize their dreams. They do not have to borrow much money as they can save their de facto “pay rise” in the form of zero income tax, for bigger equity in their entrepreneurial project someday.
3. Society’s human resources will be reallocated to more productive use. There will be lesser tax collection bureaucrats, lesser demand for tax consulting services (accounting, legal, PR, etc.) as the taxation system is more simple. If those bureaucrats and income tax consulting guys are into productive enterprises instead, then society’s production of more goods and services will expand, further creating more job opportunities.
4. People often hide their source of income, or how much they’re earning. But they flaunt their consumption – big house, big or fast cars, expensive clothes and cellphones, throwing parties, frequent travels and vacation, and so on. Taxing people on their consumption is much easier to administer because they give clear hints of what are their consumption preferences.
5. Low-income people who paid no or low income tax and low consumption tax before will not be worse off in a new situation where consumption taxes are higher. With plenty of job opportunities around, moving to high-paying jobs should be easier if one has sufficient ambition and industriousness.
6. Ultimately, consumption tax and other taxes must come down; some will have to be abolished too (as income taxes remain zero) – in a regime of small government, and bigger personal responsibilities and bigger role for voluntary organizations and civil society.
D. Timetable
1. The main goal of this taxpayers’ movement is a law that will abolish income tax, and shift revenue collection to consumption-based taxes.
2. To lessen drastic revenue adjustments, that law need not provide outright drop in income tax rate from the current 32% to zero in one year. A phase-in period of gradual reduction from 32% to zero in a period of 5 to 10 years as sales tax increase is being worked out will be instituted.
3. Meanwhile, the immediate task is to expand the number of individuals and organizations who will support this single goal. Existing organizations can affiliate with PTU. Or individuals who do not belong to any organization can form their own local taxpayers association or union (say, Pasig Taxpayers Association) and affiliate with PTU.
4. If we are strong enough, we can push a bill this year, and expect a law within 2 to 3 years (2008 or 2009).
[1] Presented during the forum on “In Search of a National Consensus”, sponsored by the Barangay San Lorenzo Business Association (BSLBA), at My Cinema, Greenbelt 3, Makati City, March 30, 2007.
[2] Secretary-General, Philippine Taxpayers Union (PTU); President, Minimal Government Movement (MGM)
Monday, March 19, 2007
Migration and Freedom 2: Taxing residents abroad
Another interesting news below -- that some Americans living abroad are giving up their US passports and their citizenship because while they pay taxes in countries where they are currently based andworking, they also have to pay taxes to the US government! Mr. Bush is really desperate in finding revenues to pursue his war in Iraq andAfghanistan (and possibly preparing for a future war in Iran and N.Korea?), finance local welfare at home, as well as paying its severa ltrillion dollars of public debt.
The number of Americans renouncing their citizenship while basedabroad may be small compared to total population of US expants aroundthe world, but the acts are more symbolic and could be on anincreasing trend. Over-taxation, no matter how "noble and lofty" the stated purposes as promised by the politicians in power, is always reprehensible.
http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/12/17/news/expat.php?page=2
More Americans abroad giving up citizenship for lower taxes
More expats say taxes make it too costly
By Doreen Carvajal
Published: 2006-12-17
A related short article I wrote last week,
Can globalization be managed?
NO. No one can "manage" globalization, whether nationally or internationally. If you want to manage something, then you need "managers" to do it. And who can be the "managers" of globalization? The US president? WB president? the IMF managing director (MD)? the WTO president? the UN Sec-Gen? the ADB president? the Chinese PM? Mr. Bill Gates? The founder of WEF? Bono?
All the names above and other names others can supply, only attempt that they can "manage" globalization. At most, I think we can call them as "trying-hard managers" of globalization. The most they can do is to put various restrictions on the movement of people, of goods and services, of capital and technology, into a certain "pace" that they want to control.
Globalization is a phenomenon naturally invented by the people around the world themselves, largely as private citizens, not as bureaucrats and politicians. Maybe they don't like their neighbors or relatives, that's why people move to another place or country. Or they hate their politicians and government, so they move to another country. Or they are paid well in their current company, but someone is willing to pay them 2x, 10x for the same work, so they migrate abroad to another company. The reasons for the mobility of people, their skills and knowledge, across the globe are as numerous as the stars at least in the Milky Way galaxy.
The internet and the web is the quickest and easiest way to bridge communication across billions of people around the globe. There are losers and winners in globalization and people mobility. The same way that there are losers and winners in isolationism and chaining people to their places.
(See also, Migration and Freedom 1: World Cup, brain gain and OFWs, February 02, 2006)
The number of Americans renouncing their citizenship while basedabroad may be small compared to total population of US expants aroundthe world, but the acts are more symbolic and could be on anincreasing trend. Over-taxation, no matter how "noble and lofty" the stated purposes as promised by the politicians in power, is always reprehensible.
http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/12/17/news/expat.php?page=2
More Americans abroad giving up citizenship for lower taxes
More expats say taxes make it too costly
By Doreen Carvajal
Published: 2006-12-17
PARIS: She is a former U.S. Marine, a native Californian and, now, a former American who prefers to remain discreet about abandoning her citizenship. After 10 years of warily considering options, she turned in her U.S. passport last month without ceremony, becoming an alien in the view of her homeland. "It's a really hard thing to do," said the woman, a 16-year residentof Geneva who had tired of the cost and time of filing yearly U.S. tax returns on top of her Swiss taxes. "I just kept putting this off. But it's my kids and the estate tax. I don't care if I die with only one Swiss franc to my name, but the U.S. shouldn't get money I earned here when I die."------
Historically, small numbers of Americans have turned in theirpassports every year for political and economic reasons, with the numbers reaching a high of about 2,000 during a Vietnam War-era boom in the 1970s. But with new tax pressures facing American expatriates due to legislation enacted in Washington this year, some international tax lawyers say they detect rising demand from citizens to renounce ties with the United States — the only developed country that taxes its citizens while they are overseas. Americans abroad are also taxed in foreign countries where they reside...
A related short article I wrote last week,
Can globalization be managed?
NO. No one can "manage" globalization, whether nationally or internationally. If you want to manage something, then you need "managers" to do it. And who can be the "managers" of globalization? The US president? WB president? the IMF managing director (MD)? the WTO president? the UN Sec-Gen? the ADB president? the Chinese PM? Mr. Bill Gates? The founder of WEF? Bono?
All the names above and other names others can supply, only attempt that they can "manage" globalization. At most, I think we can call them as "trying-hard managers" of globalization. The most they can do is to put various restrictions on the movement of people, of goods and services, of capital and technology, into a certain "pace" that they want to control.
Globalization is a phenomenon naturally invented by the people around the world themselves, largely as private citizens, not as bureaucrats and politicians. Maybe they don't like their neighbors or relatives, that's why people move to another place or country. Or they hate their politicians and government, so they move to another country. Or they are paid well in their current company, but someone is willing to pay them 2x, 10x for the same work, so they migrate abroad to another company. The reasons for the mobility of people, their skills and knowledge, across the globe are as numerous as the stars at least in the Milky Way galaxy.
The internet and the web is the quickest and easiest way to bridge communication across billions of people around the globe. There are losers and winners in globalization and people mobility. The same way that there are losers and winners in isolationism and chaining people to their places.
(See also, Migration and Freedom 1: World Cup, brain gain and OFWs, February 02, 2006)
Tax Cut 4: Tax Competition Among US States, the Laffer Curve
There is a very interesting news below -- a movement towards abolition of income tax, retention of consumption taxes to finance a smaller government, among a number of US states. If this trend will continue, Washington DC, the capital of the federal government, will be seen by many US states as a parasite: while many states are engaged in tax competition like abolition of income tax, the White House and its coterie of legislators are busy enacting new taxes (like taxing US citizens even if they are working and living abroad!) because they are busy making wars elsewhere, or promising endless foreign aid, or government to government transfer of taxpayers' money.
The free market movement in the world will become stronger if the free marketers in the US and Europe will succeed in shrinking their governments, in reducing the taxes and interventionist powers of their governments. A bloated US (and European) government is among the most convenient excuse given by politicians, bureaucrats and consultants in poorer countries, why taxes and government presence in many facets of the citizens' lives, should remain high. For instance, big foreign aid will require big local counterpart funding.
----------
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB116969533548687229.html
Rich States, Poor States
January 25, 2007
If you're searching for the next big thing in American politics, it's wise to keep an eye on the states. Here's one possibility: the abolition of state income taxes.
In Georgia, Missouri and South Carolina, Governors and state legislatures are drafting serious proposals to repeal their income taxes to promote economic development. St. Louis, one of America's most distressed cities, may overturn its wage/income tax as a way to spur urban revival.
And in Michigan, the legislature is in the last stages of phasing out its hated business income tax -- the most onerous in the land. "States are now in a ferocious competition to attract jobs and businesses," says economist Arthur Laffer, who is advising several Governors and legislators on the issue, "and one of the best ways to win this race is to abolish the state income tax."
...But the biggest target is the income tax. Newly re-elected South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford is talking of reviving his plan to phase out the income tax over 18 years. Mr. Sanford ran into opposition from the legislature in his first term, but he tells us that "I still consider this one of my top priorities and if the legislature wants to do it, I would be ecstatic."
Georgia may beat Mr. Sanford to the punch. House Republicans in Atlanta have announced that one of their top priorities is to use the half-billion-dollar budget surplus as a downpayment to "dismantle the current tax code."
House Republican Majority Leader Jerry Keen tells us the debate in Atlanta is between a flat-rate income tax and a plan that would "do away with the personal income tax but broaden the sales tax by eliminating 107 exemptions. We're committed to a pro-growth tax plan that announces to the country that Georgia is open for business."
...The idea of financing state services without an income tax is hardly radical. Nine states today -- Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming -- manage well Without one. With a few exceptions, the non-income tax states are America's Most prosperous. Meanwhile, the high income tax states, which tend to be congregated in the Northeast, keep surrendering jobs, people, and voters to the South and West...
---------
On the Laffer Curve and Optimal Tax Rate
The Laffer curve is a graph showing an optimal level of tax rate where government revenues reach maximum level. If the tax rate further increases, say from 30% to 40%, revenues go down as people would rather reduce work and have more sleep and leisure since more income means more taxes to be surrendered to the government. Or people would rather misdeclare their income to evade paying more taxes, or bribe tax collectors, resulting in lower revenues than projected.
The concept was developed by an American economist, Prof. ArthurLaffer. He further argued that lower taxes result in lower prices, higher demand, leading to higher production and hence, bigger economic pie and higher taxable base. We can add that lower taxes or tax cuts are tantamount to pay hike to everyone whose monthly and yearly income are automatically deducted with government withholding taxes. Thus, pay hike means more pockets for the people, more spending power, more demand and consumption, and so on.
Taxes are always distortionary. You remove 1/3 to ½ of a productive person's monthly income and savings, purportedly for whatever welfarist and missionary functions by the state, you immediately alterthe working, spending and savings attitude of that person. For instance, instead of bringing his family to dream vacations in thePhilippines (Boracay, Coron-Palawan, Puerto Galera, Baguio, etc.) twice a year – that creates jobs to many people living and working there – they only go there once every 2 years. Because the equivalentvalue of his expenses for such holiday was confiscated by the government. And government, once it holds the money, can decide whether to improve the justice system that will benefit everyone, or improve the chances for re-election of the incumbent politicians through endless pork barrel or charter-change campaigns.
So, since taxes are distortionary because they are forced collections, taxes should be few and small. That is, the distortions should be few and small.
In a way, you can have 2 (or more) Laffer curves, depending on yourpurpose. For instance:
Laffer curve 1 – a level of tax rate that will finance the current and projected levelof government expenditures. For statist and interventionist politicians, plus their coterie of equally statist consultants, staff and bureaucrats, retain the current government expenditures of 50-60%of GDP (the current level in many western & northern European countries), then devise a tax rate that will somehow give you a tax & "non-tax" (but still compulsory payment to government, like driver's license fee, passport fee…) revenues of 50-60% of GDP.
Laffer curve 2 – a level of tax rate to really unburden taxpayers and finance a government that is just focused on a few, limited, andimportant function – protect lives, properties, and individual liberties of the citizens. Because the more functions and welfarism that a government intends to do, the more taxes, fees and penalties itwill collect and confiscate from the citizens.
The Laffer curve concept is a beautiful guide to remind governments when they should stop confiscating a big portion of the income and savings of their citizens. It is also a good reminder to socialists, welfarists, and other advocates of wanton confiscation of income andsavings of productive people, that there is a limit to such philosophy based on forced equality, if not envy.
The free market movement in the world will become stronger if the free marketers in the US and Europe will succeed in shrinking their governments, in reducing the taxes and interventionist powers of their governments. A bloated US (and European) government is among the most convenient excuse given by politicians, bureaucrats and consultants in poorer countries, why taxes and government presence in many facets of the citizens' lives, should remain high. For instance, big foreign aid will require big local counterpart funding.
----------
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB116969533548687229.html
Rich States, Poor States
January 25, 2007
If you're searching for the next big thing in American politics, it's wise to keep an eye on the states. Here's one possibility: the abolition of state income taxes.
In Georgia, Missouri and South Carolina, Governors and state legislatures are drafting serious proposals to repeal their income taxes to promote economic development. St. Louis, one of America's most distressed cities, may overturn its wage/income tax as a way to spur urban revival.
And in Michigan, the legislature is in the last stages of phasing out its hated business income tax -- the most onerous in the land. "States are now in a ferocious competition to attract jobs and businesses," says economist Arthur Laffer, who is advising several Governors and legislators on the issue, "and one of the best ways to win this race is to abolish the state income tax."
...But the biggest target is the income tax. Newly re-elected South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford is talking of reviving his plan to phase out the income tax over 18 years. Mr. Sanford ran into opposition from the legislature in his first term, but he tells us that "I still consider this one of my top priorities and if the legislature wants to do it, I would be ecstatic."
Georgia may beat Mr. Sanford to the punch. House Republicans in Atlanta have announced that one of their top priorities is to use the half-billion-dollar budget surplus as a downpayment to "dismantle the current tax code."
House Republican Majority Leader Jerry Keen tells us the debate in Atlanta is between a flat-rate income tax and a plan that would "do away with the personal income tax but broaden the sales tax by eliminating 107 exemptions. We're committed to a pro-growth tax plan that announces to the country that Georgia is open for business."
...The idea of financing state services without an income tax is hardly radical. Nine states today -- Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming -- manage well Without one. With a few exceptions, the non-income tax states are America's Most prosperous. Meanwhile, the high income tax states, which tend to be congregated in the Northeast, keep surrendering jobs, people, and voters to the South and West...
---------
On the Laffer Curve and Optimal Tax Rate
The Laffer curve is a graph showing an optimal level of tax rate where government revenues reach maximum level. If the tax rate further increases, say from 30% to 40%, revenues go down as people would rather reduce work and have more sleep and leisure since more income means more taxes to be surrendered to the government. Or people would rather misdeclare their income to evade paying more taxes, or bribe tax collectors, resulting in lower revenues than projected.
The concept was developed by an American economist, Prof. ArthurLaffer. He further argued that lower taxes result in lower prices, higher demand, leading to higher production and hence, bigger economic pie and higher taxable base. We can add that lower taxes or tax cuts are tantamount to pay hike to everyone whose monthly and yearly income are automatically deducted with government withholding taxes. Thus, pay hike means more pockets for the people, more spending power, more demand and consumption, and so on.
Taxes are always distortionary. You remove 1/3 to ½ of a productive person's monthly income and savings, purportedly for whatever welfarist and missionary functions by the state, you immediately alterthe working, spending and savings attitude of that person. For instance, instead of bringing his family to dream vacations in thePhilippines (Boracay, Coron-Palawan, Puerto Galera, Baguio, etc.) twice a year – that creates jobs to many people living and working there – they only go there once every 2 years. Because the equivalentvalue of his expenses for such holiday was confiscated by the government. And government, once it holds the money, can decide whether to improve the justice system that will benefit everyone, or improve the chances for re-election of the incumbent politicians through endless pork barrel or charter-change campaigns.
So, since taxes are distortionary because they are forced collections, taxes should be few and small. That is, the distortions should be few and small.
In a way, you can have 2 (or more) Laffer curves, depending on yourpurpose. For instance:
Laffer curve 1 – a level of tax rate that will finance the current and projected levelof government expenditures. For statist and interventionist politicians, plus their coterie of equally statist consultants, staff and bureaucrats, retain the current government expenditures of 50-60%of GDP (the current level in many western & northern European countries), then devise a tax rate that will somehow give you a tax & "non-tax" (but still compulsory payment to government, like driver's license fee, passport fee…) revenues of 50-60% of GDP.
Laffer curve 2 – a level of tax rate to really unburden taxpayers and finance a government that is just focused on a few, limited, andimportant function – protect lives, properties, and individual liberties of the citizens. Because the more functions and welfarism that a government intends to do, the more taxes, fees and penalties itwill collect and confiscate from the citizens.
The Laffer curve concept is a beautiful guide to remind governments when they should stop confiscating a big portion of the income and savings of their citizens. It is also a good reminder to socialists, welfarists, and other advocates of wanton confiscation of income andsavings of productive people, that there is a limit to such philosophy based on forced equality, if not envy.
Monday, March 12, 2007
Business Bureaucracy 1: Avoiding government: Egyptian experience
A report from the International Herald Tribune last Feb. 28, 2007, "Egyptians look to God, not government, for help" (by Michael Slackman), said:
"...Cairo is home to 15 million and often described as the center of the Arab world, an incubator of culture and ideas... The fisherman on the Nile, the shepherd in the road and residents ofso- called informal communities say their experiences navigating city life have taught them the same lessons: the government is not there to better their lives; advancement is based on connections and bribes; the central authority is at best a benign force to be avoided. "Everything is from God," said Mezar, the fisherman, who was speaking practically, not theologically. "There is no such thing as government. The government is one thing and we are something else. What am I going to get from the government?"
...One brick in the foundation of single-party rule has been public resignation. There is no widespread expectation that the authorities will give the common man a voice, and so there is rarely any outrage when they do not. The fisherman, the shepherd and Fathy all said that the most they could hope for from the government was that it stay out of their lives. "We hope God keeps the municipality away from us," Sayed said as hesat in a wooden chair, surveying his fetid flock of goats and sheepwith headlights streaming by.
Such a feeling of separation is one reason that the leadership has been able to clamp down on opposition political activities without incurring widespread public wrath, political analysts say." People see the government as something quite foreign or removed from their lives," said Diane Singerman, a professor in government at the American University in Washington who has written extensively aboutCairo. "Commuters to the city, or poor peddlers and working people, do not see the government as particularly interested in their lives, andthey also see politics as quite elite and risky and something to stayaway from."
Officials say part of the disillusionment comes from unrealistic expectations, a holdover from the heady days of Gamal Abdel Nasser, the Egyptian leader from 1954 to 1970, when government jobs were deemed a right and cradle-to- grave care a promise...
Rest of article at
http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/02/28/news/cairo.php
This feeling by the poor in Cairo could be the feeling of most Egyptian taxpayers, where the costs of government -- the myriads of taxes, fees, regulations, inspections, accreditations -- are very clear but the benefits are minimal, if any.
Once a government bureaucracy has reached a certain level of"bigness", it acquires a life of its own and its main purpose is to perpetuate itself, if not expand further. In that case, government service becomes "self service" and those in the private sector, thosewho toil a lot to feed an ever-expanding bureaucracy, are engaged in real "public service" based on voluntary exchange.
The Philippine bureaucracy as a whole I think, has not reached that level yet. Many local government bureaucracies though, have bad attitude problem, that those wanting to become entrepreneurs and job creators are seen as potential labor exploiters, potential environmental pests, andpotential perpetuators of social inequality. Hence, they must be strictly regulated even before they can start opening up their business.
"...Cairo is home to 15 million and often described as the center of the Arab world, an incubator of culture and ideas... The fisherman on the Nile, the shepherd in the road and residents ofso- called informal communities say their experiences navigating city life have taught them the same lessons: the government is not there to better their lives; advancement is based on connections and bribes; the central authority is at best a benign force to be avoided. "Everything is from God," said Mezar, the fisherman, who was speaking practically, not theologically. "There is no such thing as government. The government is one thing and we are something else. What am I going to get from the government?"
...One brick in the foundation of single-party rule has been public resignation. There is no widespread expectation that the authorities will give the common man a voice, and so there is rarely any outrage when they do not. The fisherman, the shepherd and Fathy all said that the most they could hope for from the government was that it stay out of their lives. "We hope God keeps the municipality away from us," Sayed said as hesat in a wooden chair, surveying his fetid flock of goats and sheepwith headlights streaming by.
Such a feeling of separation is one reason that the leadership has been able to clamp down on opposition political activities without incurring widespread public wrath, political analysts say." People see the government as something quite foreign or removed from their lives," said Diane Singerman, a professor in government at the American University in Washington who has written extensively aboutCairo. "Commuters to the city, or poor peddlers and working people, do not see the government as particularly interested in their lives, andthey also see politics as quite elite and risky and something to stayaway from."
Officials say part of the disillusionment comes from unrealistic expectations, a holdover from the heady days of Gamal Abdel Nasser, the Egyptian leader from 1954 to 1970, when government jobs were deemed a right and cradle-to- grave care a promise...
Rest of article at
http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/02/28/news/cairo.php
This feeling by the poor in Cairo could be the feeling of most Egyptian taxpayers, where the costs of government -- the myriads of taxes, fees, regulations, inspections, accreditations -- are very clear but the benefits are minimal, if any.
Once a government bureaucracy has reached a certain level of"bigness", it acquires a life of its own and its main purpose is to perpetuate itself, if not expand further. In that case, government service becomes "self service" and those in the private sector, thosewho toil a lot to feed an ever-expanding bureaucracy, are engaged in real "public service" based on voluntary exchange.
The Philippine bureaucracy as a whole I think, has not reached that level yet. Many local government bureaucracies though, have bad attitude problem, that those wanting to become entrepreneurs and job creators are seen as potential labor exploiters, potential environmental pests, andpotential perpetuators of social inequality. Hence, they must be strictly regulated even before they can start opening up their business.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)