Showing posts with label Tony la Vina. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tony la Vina. Show all posts

Saturday, February 06, 2016

Energy 57, Tony la Vina's anti-coal alarmism

Aside from Greenpeace, World Wildlife Fund (WWF), Oxfam and other big environmental NGOs, one prominent anti-coal (and anti-fossil fuels, anti-mining, anti-...) crusader to "save the planet" is Atty. Tony la Vina, outgoing Dean of the Ateneo School of Government. 

In his 3 recent columns (January 16, January 26, February 06, 2016) in The Standard, he articulated various anti-coal alarmism claims, below. I added some data and 2 articles from WUWT by Eric Worral. 


The various "planet saviours" celebrated big time last December during the UN FCCC's COP 21 in Paris, saying they signed a deal that will further limit fossil fuels like coal. But look at the chart -- coal power is projected to experience the biggest rise and share to total global energy use. See WUWT, Is our certain fate a coal-burning climate apocalypse? No! July 21, 2015.

In Tony LV's article today in The Standard, Coal is not least costly technology, he argued that 

"When we factor in the environmental, health and social impacts of coal on communities—as we should—operating coal-fired power plants bear costs that are unfortunately paid for by people who will be affected the most by the ill effects of CFPPs. These costs are not often accounted for in the electricity price because they are considered externalities."

Really? The clear alternative to coal aside from more natural gas (another fossil fuel) is frequent brownouts, frequent electricity outage. And what happens if there is frequent brownout? (a) More crimes at night as criminals love darkness, (b) more road accidents, (c) more fires as more people use candles, and (d) more air and noise pollution as more people buy and use gensets that noisily run on diesel.

Why? Because electricity from coal comprises more than one-half of actual power production in Luzon grid including Metro Manila in the first half of 2015. Another fossil fuel, natural gas, produced nearly one-third of the grid's actual power generation. In the Visayas grid, coal produces almost 40% of power generation there.


Source: Sec. Zenaida Y. Monsada, ENERGY PROSPECTS FOR THE PHILIPPINES, 
EPDP Conference 2016, 12-13 January 2016, New World Hotel, Makati City.

Tony LV also wrote,

"In a previous column, I described how these pollutants harm the environment; the same also result in adverse health impact. Long-term effects of pollutants from CFPPs include respiratory, cardiovascular and neurological diseases."

Really? As of 2014, Vietnam and Malaysia have nearly 2x coal power consumption than the PH. Taiwan and Indonesia have nearly 4x and 6x coal consumption than PH. S. Korea has nearly 8x and Japan nearly 12x coal consumption than PH. 

Not to mention also huge coal power consumption by Germany, Russia, India, USA and China.


Do we see massive health problems on those countries that have more coal plants than the PH? If one is into emotionalism and alarmism, the answer is Yes. If one is into realism and facts, the answer is No. 

Among the silent goals of anti-coal alarmism and emotionalism is to have more climate junkets, endless global junkets, for many years and decades, as "planet saviours" and climate negotiators. Even Japan considers high tech coal plants as saving the planet. More than 1,000 new coal plants in Asia alone coming up. http://wattsupwiththat.com/.../japan-building-coal.../
-------------

See also:

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Climate Tricks 13: Block Skeptics and Keep Fooling the Public

One common practice of the man-made warming leaders and campaigners is to block off people who often question their religion. I have confirmed that once more two days ago when I checked my twitter account. I have observed earlier that after questioning several tweets by Greenpeace Philippines, they blocked me from following them, I posted it here, Greenpeace is Blocking You, November 19, 2011.

When I checked again last Monday, this is the result.


Cowards, as usual. They only need people who will pat them in the back as "planet saviors". Well, at least I sent them this tweet, "cowards in debates..."

Another cousin or sibling in cowardice but sibling in climate alarmism and noise is the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), their WWF-Philippine office also blocked me. No tears guys, sorry.


Oh, the perennial Philippine "climate negotiator" for two decades or more, Dean of the Ateneo School of Government (ASoG), Atty. Tony La Vina, also do not like me questioning his "save the planet" mantra. But at least I sent this tweet to him, "Warming fanatics blocking me..."


Tuesday, January 03, 2012

Climate Tricks 1: 4.5 Billion People to Die This Year

Starting this year, I am changing the thread title from "Climate Stupidity" to "Climate Tricks". Some friends suggested that the former sounds too brutal and combative. I agree, somehow, so I will mellow down, will use the latter. After all, AGW has become scary and threatening due to various tricks used by the proponents of that hypothesis, like the "hockey stick" graph of global temperature as tricked by Prof. Michael Mann of Penn State U. And that is why it's also called "Mann-made warming."

This headline from The Canadian made just four years ago is really scary. Some 4.5 billion of us in this planet could die this year because of global warming. Anthony Watts of WUWT made this blog entry two days ago:


Be careful today and tonight, billions may die

UPDATE: January 1st, 2012 – still here, no reports of mass deaths at the last minute. – Anthony
Global warming may go on a last minute rampage. Maybe best to just stay at home and lock your doors, bar your windows, and turn your air conditioner on. If you live near the coast, head for high ground. Deaths due to drinking and  driving will be nothing compared to this.
This story appeared in The Canadian January 8th, 2007, it’s been a countdown example of stupidity ever since. Unbelievably, it is still on their website. Note today’s date....

Now, aren't you scared?

Also four years ago, Al Gore boldly predicted of an ice-free Arctic by 2014. Steven Goddard posted,

The 2007 Nobel Peace Prize
January 3, 2012


The Nobel Peace Prize winner in 2007 was of course sex poodle Al Gore and theHimalayas gone by 2035 IPCC. In his acceptance speech, Al Gore compared his brave work (lying to children for a fast buck) to that of fighting the Nazis. He predicted an ice-free Arctic by 2014.
We, the human species, are confronting a planetary emergency – a threat to the survival of our civilization that is gathering ominous and destructive potential even as we gather here. But there is hopeful news as well: we have the ability to solve this crisis and avoid the worst – though not all – of its consequences, if we act boldly, decisively and quickly.
However, despite a growing number of honorable exceptions, too many of the world’s leaders are still best described in the words Winston Churchill applied to those who ignored Adolf Hitler’s threat: “They go on in strange paradox, decided only to be undecided, resolved to be irresolute, adamant for drift, solid for fluidity, all powerful to be impotent.”
Last September 21, as the Northern Hemisphere tilted away from the sun, scientists reported with unprecedented distress that the North Polar ice cap is “falling off a cliff.” One ….  new study, to be presented by U.S. Navy researchers later this week, warns it could happen in as little as 7 years.
Al Gore

Ok, here is the sea ice extent in the Arctic as of yesterday, January 2, 2012. Graph is from the Danish Meteorological Institute (DMI), Center for Ocean and Ice. The lowest level in 2011 was about 4.2 million sq. kms. of ice sometime in late September. The highest level was about 11.2 million sq. kms. of ice sometime in early March 2011.

The satellite picture as of two days ago, January 1, 2012, is from the National Snow and Ice Data Center (NSIDC).


Anything so scary and threatening about the Arctic ice? Hard data says No, while Al Gore and the UN -- IPCC, FCCC, WMO, UNEP, etc. -- say Yes.

Meanwhile, here's the end-December 2011 global air and tropospheric temperature anomaly, from Dr. Roy Spencer of UAH, http://www.drroyspencer.com/


UAH Global Temperature Update for Dec. 2011: +0.13 deg. C

January 3rd, 2012
The global average lower tropospheric temperature anomaly for December, 2011 remained about the same November, +0.13 deg. C (click on the image for the full-size version):
The 3rd order polynomial fit to the data (courtesy of Excel) is for entertainment purposes only, and should not be construed as having any predictive value whatsoever.
Here are the monthly stats for 2010 and 2011:

YR MON GLOBAL NH SH TROPICS
2010 1 +0.542 +0.675 +0.410 +0.635
2010 2 +0.510 +0.553 +0.466 +0.759
2010 3 +0.554 +0.665 +0.443 +0.721
2010 4 +0.400 +0.606 +0.193 +0.633
2010 5 +0.454 +0.642 +0.265 +0.706
2010 6 +0.385 +0.482 +0.287 +0.485
2010 7 +0.419 +0.558 +0.280 +0.370
2010 8 +0.441 +0.579 +0.304 +0.321
2010 9 +0.477 +0.410 +0.545 +0.237
2010 10 +0.306 +0.257 +0.356 +0.106
2010 11 +0.273 +0.372 +0.173 -0.117
2010 12 +0.181 +0.217 +0.145 -0.222
2011 1 -0.010 -0.055 +0.036 -0.372
2011 2 -0.020 -0.042 +0.002 -0.348
2011 3 -0.101 -0.073 -0.128 -0.342
2011 4 +0.117 +0.195 +0.039 -0.229
2011 5 +0.133 +0.145 +0.121 -0.043
2011 6 +0.315 +0.379 +0.250 +0.233
2011 7 +0.374 +0.344 +0.404 +0.204
2011 8 +0.327 +0.321 +0.332 +0.155
2011 9 +0.289 +0.304 +0.274 +0.178
2011 10 +0.116 +0.169 +0.062 -0.054
2011 11 +0.123 +0.075 +0.170 +0.024
2011 12 +0.127 +0.197 +0.057 +0.043


Finally, there will be a symposium on geology and climate (alarmism) on Friday in UP.

“Your Daily Dose of Earth Science” Symposium

January 5, 2012
Audio-Visual Room, National Institute of Geological Sciences (NIGS)
University of the Philippines, Diliman, Quezon City

0905 Welcome Remarks
Dean Jose Maria Balmaceda, UP College of Science

0920 Keynote Address
Secretary Mario G. Montejo, Department of Science and Technology

1000 Climate Change after Durban
Dean Antonio G. M. La Viña (Dean, Ateneo School of Government)

1030 Renewable Energy Outlook
Dir. Mario C. Marasigan (Director IV, Renewable Energy Management Bureau, Department of Energy)

1100 Trends in Geosciences Education in the Philippines
Dr. Graciano P. Yumul Jr.
(Undersecretary for Research and Development, Department of Science & Technology)

1130 Promoting a Culture of Safety, Health, Environmental Protection and Social Development (SHES) in the Mining Industry
Engr. Louie R. Sarmiento (President, Philippine Mine Safety and Environment Association)

1330 Geology and the Management of Our Water Resources
Dr. Carlos Primo C. David (Professor, UP National Institute of Geological Sciences)

1400 Geology - Main Tool in Mineral Discoveries
Mr. Hernulfo B. Ruelo & Mr. Ciceron A. Angeles Jr. (Consultants)

1430 Can Nuclear Waste be Disposed of Safely?
Dr. Carlo A. Arcilla (Director, UP National Institute of Geological Sciences)

1530 Metro Manila Earthquake Impact Reduction Study
Dr. Renato U. Solidum Jr. (Director, Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology)

1600 The National Geohazards Mapping & Assessment Program of the Mines & Geosciences Bureau-Department of Environment & Natural Resources
Dr. Karlo L. Queaño (Supervising Science Research Specialist, Mines & Geosciences Bureau)